Protecting Homeownership: CARP’s Fight Against the Proposed Home Equity Tax

For millions of Canadians, homeownership represents financial security, a lifetime of savings, and a safety net for retirement. The Canadian Association of Retired Persons (CARP) is leading the fight against a proposed Home Equity Tax – a policy that threatens seniors, homeowners, and their families. CARP believes taxing the equity in homes is an unfair penalty for hard-working Canadians who have spent years building that equity through responsible financial planning.

What Is the Home Equity Tax?

A home equity tax would apply to the equity Canadians have built up in their homes – the difference between the home’s current market value and the price originally paid for the home, minus any remaining mortgage balance. This tax would represent a significant financial burden, especially for seniors, many of whom rely on their home equity as their largest source of retirement savings.

Key Mechanisms of the Tax:

• Tax applied at the time of sale or transfer of ownership.
• Potential annual or periodic tax assessments on home equity value.
• Disproportionate impact on long-time homeowners in regions with rising housing prices.

Impact on Seniors and Homeowners

1. Seniors on Fixed Incomes:
   For retirees, a Home Equity Tax would erode the savings they depend on to fund their retirement. Seniors often rely on their home equity to cover living expenses, healthcare costs, and aging in place. Adding a tax on this essential asset creates additional financial stress.
   Example:
   A senior who bought their home for $250,000 in the 1980s may now see its market value rise to $1.2 million. Even with no mortgage, a Home Equity Tax would force them to pay on the increased value – despite living modestly and relying on that equity for retirement.
2. Middle-Class Homeowners:
   For Canadians in their 40s and 50s, paying off a mortgage is a key part of financial security. A Home Equity Tax punishes responsible homeowners for building equity, jeopardizing their ability to plan for retirement.
   Long-Term Effect:
   • Slows down wealth accumulation for future generations.
   • Forces families to rethink their financial goals and risk additional debt.
3. Intergenerational Wealth Transfer:
   For many Canadians, a home is a legacy that can be passed on to children and grandchildren. A Home Equity Tax threatens this transfer of wealth, reducing the ability to support younger generations in achieving financial stability.

International Comparisons

Australia

• Policies resembling a Home Equity Tax have led to backlash. Many seniors were forced to sell homes they had lived in for decades.

United Kingdom

• The UK experimented with similar tax policies, only to repeal them after widespread opposition. Homeowners experienced unexpected financial burdens, creating instability in local housing markets.

New Zealand

• Wealth taxes targeting home equity were implemented but criticized for disproportionately affecting retirees, leading to policy reversals.

Key Lesson:
Home Equity Taxes are often proposed as a solution to affordability but create more problems than they solve, particularly for seniors and homeowners.

CARP’s Position: Protecting Homeownership

CARP strongly opposes any form of a Home Equity Tax. Homeownership has long been a cornerstone of Canadian life – a way for families to secure their future and enjoy financial independence. Introducing a tax on home equity punishes success, unfairly targets seniors, and undermines financial security.

Key Reasons for Opposition:

1. Unfair to Seniors: Seniors have already contributed through years of taxes and savings. They should not be penalized in retirement.
2. Harms Middle-Class Families: Younger homeowners working hard to pay off their mortgages would face significant financial setbacks.
3. Breaks the Promise of Homeownership: Canadians have been promised that homeownership is a path to financial security. A Home Equity Tax shatters that promise.

CARP’s Solutions:

Rather than introducing unfair taxes that target seniors and homeowners, CARP advocates for:

• Targeted Affordable Housing Policies: Address housing affordability through new construction, incentives for first-time buyers, and support for low-income renters.
• Preservation of Retirement Savings: Protect seniors’ ability to rely on home equity as a financial safety net.
• Fair and Equitable Taxation: Ensure policies do not disproportionately burden middle-class families and retirees.

A Message from CARP President, Rudy Buttignol, C.M. (Click to Read)

Listen to one of our radio spots :

In the News