This article was originally published in the Vancouver Observer. To view this article and other ones like it on the Vancouver Observer website, please click here.
Canada’s advocacy group for seniors is crying foul after another Conservative government announcement on old age pensions yesterday revealed… nothing new at all.
During a highly anticipated pensions speech yesterday, Human Resources Minister Diane Finley added her weight to an increasingly cloudy debate on changes to Canada’s Old Age Security (OAS) system, the latest since Prime Minister Stephen Harper boasted of coming reforms to stave off costs in Davos, Switzerland several weeks ago.
“They are manufacturing a crisis,” said Susan Eng, advocacy vice president of CARP: A New Vision of Aging, in an extensive interview with the Vancouver Observer. “I am disappointed they would treat an important issue like this.
“There’s absolutely no need for them to do it this way… reciting the same basic talking points which have not been accepted by people. Because the government has not given any real details, everybody is guessing. Our members and others like them are fearing the worst.”
CARP (formerly the Canadian Association of Retired Persons) has launched a “Hands Off OAS” campaign, and said that cuts to pensions – speculated to include extending the retirement age from 65 to 67 – will hurt the poorest Canadians, many of whom are seniors. According to CARP, 250,000 seniors fall into the low-income rate.
The latest salvo in the pensions controversy came after Finley defended her government’s as-yet undefined pension reform – namely, a coming wave of retiring Baby Boomers, demographic shifts, and escalating costs to the system – at a major speech Tuesday before the Canadian Club in Toronto.
Seniors outraged over erosion of safety net
Implicitly addressing critics like CARP and the New Democratic Party (NDP), Finley insisted that pension reform “is not a crisis we invented” – but the bulk of her speech seemed aimed at younger Canadians, not current retirees who the government said will be unaffected.
The government has asserted that OAS costs will skyrocket from today’s $36 billion to $108 billion by 2030.
“People who are middle age and younger today … can be assured that they will have these social programs properly funded, fiscally responsible, that they’ll be there for them in the future,” she told the Canada Club audience, which included Eng. “It’s the next generations of Canadians who will have to shoulder the burden,” she said. “The next generations who will have their own families to raise, their own mortgages to pay, their own student and household debt to manage.
“Inaction is simply not an option. Something must be done.”
In earlier comments by Finance Minister Jim Flaherty, he suggested that pension changes would not kick in until at least 2020, but Flaherty’s staffers subsequently clarified the record that earlier pension reforms may be in the works. By contrast, Finley said the upcoming budget will begin the reforms.
“Although policy hasn’t yet been announced, I can tell you that the upcoming budget will ensure steps to protect retirement income,” she said. “I personally assure that there will be no changes for seniors currently collecting benefits. Nor will there be any impacts for anyone close to retirement.”
But CARP members – who are primarily but not exclusively retired – are on the whole outraged, according to internal polls cited by Eng.
“For lower-income people, this is going to have a massive impact,” she said. “(The Conservatives) say nothing about protecting them, even though they’ve had ample opportunity; it’s been three weeks since they dropped the bombshell (in Davos).
“The ones hurt most by this change are low-income people who are just hanging on. (Seniors) know how much it takes to make ends meet – they don’t want this effected for their children and grandchildren. This is the population that grew up in the ’60s and ’70s – they care about Canada’s social safety net.”